![]() |
| Our... villain. Rusty never learns. |
Just like how The Twin Dilemma bottoms the list every time the Classic Stories are judged, Love And Monsters is considered the nadir of the new series. This is RTD's writing at its very, very worst, and Love And Monsters is so unpleasant and silly that it's not exactly a glowing recommendation for the so-called, "Saviour of Doctor Who." The first "Doctor-Lite" episode, it showed us a side of the series that a lot of people never want to see again.
The story surrounds Elton Pope (Marc Warren) and his fascination with The Doctor. It's told initially through a video diary, Elton discussing his initial encounters with The Doctor and how he joined a group with his girlfriend Ursula, (LInDA), focussed on finding him. While they enjoy themselves by doing arts-and-crafts materials, they are propositioned by evil-looking Victor Kennedy (comedian Peter Kay) to become more organised in their search. After a crazy, Scooby-Doo style run-in, Elton is tasked with infiltrating Jackie Tyler to find out about Rose. At the same time, the group is blissfully unaware that members of their group are disappearing. Soon only Elton and Ursula are left, and it's revealed that Victor is in fact a relative of the Slitheen called the Absorbaloff that's been eating people via touch. Ursula is thereforth absorbed. The Doctor turns up for the last five minutes, and Elton manages to defeat the Absorbaloff by somehow letting him be absorbed by the earth. As one last present, The Doc returns Ursula in the form of a face in a paving slab.
The first attempt at a Doctor-Lite did what it could to ret-con Elton into the rest of the series' events, and it felt very, very forced because of that. Elton's stranger speech patterns and his borderline obsession with The Doctor meant that instead of just being slightly nerdy, Elton often comes across as seriously mentally ill. You can tell, however, that he is at least attempting to act. Peter Kay is only a convincing actor when portraying things of his own creation, and as Kennedy/The Absorbaloff he is painfully hammy in the least enjoyable way. Count Grendel is fun ham. Kennedy is just a caricature.
![]() |
| LInDA. Or, according to RTD, the Doctor Who Appreciation Society. |
One of the big points of a Doctor Lite is that when he does appear it's very condensed and thus must be very good. True to form, Ten's five minutes paint him as a power-mad asshole content to consign a woman to a life as an immortal, blow-job giving paving slab. Yeah, blow-job. That's a joke at the end. A kid inspired this episode.
A key argument in favour of this episode is how it acts as an examination of Doctor Who fandom; LInDA is the enthusiastic fan club exploring Doctor Who's foibles while Kennedy is the obnoxious fans who ruin the fun for everyone else. Which, forgetting how terrible the execution was, isn't a bad idea. But then Elton is portrayed as near-mentally insane and permenantly scarred by his experiences with The Doctor, and The Doctor ultimately fucks Ursula's existence up forever. That's not exactly positive. Also, Kennedy is basically a big Take That towards fan Ian Levine, believed part-author of Attack of the Cybermen who has been one of the program's most vocal fans and critics for the past thirty years. This isn't loving at all; this is hateful, and really bad form on Russell's part.
| Rusty's mind is wrong on so many levels. |
Love and Monsters isn't as mindless as New Earth, but it replaces banality with unwarranted stupidity. The writing is insulting, the characters either insane or stupid and the plot is bearly recognisable as Doctor Who. Love and Monsters, unlike its fellow The Twin Dilemma, certainly does deserve its place at the bottom of the New Series pile and should forever be remembered as how not to make Doctor Who.
Thanks.
And, just because I can, I'll conclude this forthnight's set of Season 28 reviews with School Reunion on Saturday




